Sixty-Eight Months of Pay Was Not the Point

Micron's Taiwan unions turned down up to 68 months of pay. A bonus decided after the profits is a gift; a formula agreed before is a share.

Share

Sixty-eight months of pay. That was the top of the range Micron offered its employees in Taiwan for fiscal 2026, according to Business Today in September, which described the offer as total rewards equivalent to 35 to 68 months of pay. The two unions at its Taoyuan and Taichung plants, which represent nearly 12,000 of its roughly 15,000 workers there, turned it down. They asked for a one-off bonus of 83 months and, more importantly, a permanent rule giving 15 percent of operating profit to workers, paid every quarter.

On Wednesday Micron signed an agreement with its Taichung union on terms that, according to Micron Taiwan's chairman, Donghui Lu, include a new quarterly profit-sharing bonus tied to earnings. On Thursday eleven officials of the Taoyuan union began a 24-hour strike anyway, saying their representatives' views had not been adequately included. The union said it was not meant to disrupt production. Focus Taiwan reported that the union's chairman, Jerry Lin, insisted that "our four demands have never changed." One of them, from the start, was a standing formula rather than a discretionary bonus.

Most people's first reaction to "rejected 68 months of pay" is somewhere between disbelief and irritation. Mine was too. Then I tried to say who, exactly, those profits belong to, and found I couldn't.

The money comes from memory chips, including the high-bandwidth memory that AI servers can't run without, which Micron makes. Demand for it exploded because a handful of companies elsewhere decided to spend hundreds of billions on data centers. Nobody on the Taoyuan fab floor caused that. Neither did Micron's shareholders. Neither, really, did Micron's executives, beyond having bet on the right kind of chip years ago. Most of this profit is a windfall: value that arrived because the world changed around a factory, not because anyone in it worked dramatically harder or chose dramatically better.

That makes it a near-perfect test of what deserving means. If wealth belongs to those who earned it, a windfall belongs to nobody, and every claim on it is just a negotiation dressed up as a principle.

The owners' case is better than the slogan "the shareholders take everything" makes it sound. Memory chips are a brutally cyclical business. When prices crash, the factory still pays salaries, and the losses land on the people who own it. Shareholders carry the downside of luck, so they keep the upside. Workers are paid steadily precisely so they don't have to carry that risk. To demand a fixed share of the good years, after drawing full salaries through the bad ones, is to ask for the insurance and the lottery ticket at once. And 68 months is not stinginess; it's a sum most workers on earth will never see.

The workers' case is not really about effort either, and the most thoughtful version of it doesn't pretend to be. It is about who the factory is. A fab is not a pile of machines that happened to be lying around when the boom came. It is years of tacit knowledge about how to run those machines at a yield that matters, held in the hands and heads of the people on shift. A windfall arrives at a place, and the place is made partly of them. If no one earned it, then the people whose lives are bound to that place have at least as good a claim as people whose relationship to it is a line in a portfolio, owners of a company headquartered on the other side of the Pacific.

Neither side will much like my answer. I don't think anyone deserves a windfall. I think the fairest way to split luck is a rule agreed before you know how lucky you'll be. That is, roughly, the intuition behind John Rawls's veil of ignorance: if you have to choose the rules without knowing your place in them, you choose rules you could defend from any seat. A bonus decided after the profits are known is a gift, and gifts make the receiver a petitioner. A formula agreed in advance is a share, and shares make the receiver a partner. That is why I think the union is right to care more about the 15 percent mechanism than about the 83 months, and why the company's generous number didn't end the fight. Generosity is a power the giver keeps.

The formula has costs of its own. A formula written in a boom will be fought over in the bust, and the workers who bargained for 15 percent of profit may discover what 15 percent of a loss feels like in fewer hires and frozen salaries. Rawls's veil also has no obvious place for the people outside the room. The technician at a struggling auto-parts plant down the road has the same skills, the same hours, and none of the luck. A rule that shares a windfall between owners and the workers who happened to be standing near it is still a rule that keeps it among the fortunate.

The scene from Thursday says more than the numbers. Eleven people walked out for a day, carefully, so as not to stop the line, over whether the money they were already being offered should come as a gift or as a right. Most of the coverage treated that as a bonus dispute. The company has offered up to 68 months. What the union is asking for is a different kind of ownership, and Micron has not yet said it will give it.

— The Andes