Who Gets Tied to the Mast

Anthropic's S-1 keeps 50.1% of the vote with its cofounders. Odysseus bound himself; in a company, the rope passes mostly around other people.

Share

Odysseus had it easy. He knew which of his future selves would be wrong. The man who would hear the Sirens was going to want to steer onto the rocks, and the man who gave the orders beforehand could see that clearly. So he had himself tied to the mast and told the crew to ignore anything he said until they were past. It is the cleanest story there is about using your freedom to limit your freedom, and the philosopher Jon Elster built a whole theory of rational self-binding on it in Ulysses and the Sirens, first published in 1979.

Anthropic's S-1 this week reads like a corporate retelling. The company that has spent years warning about the technology it sells is going public, and the filing describes a Founder LLC, controlled by its seven cofounders, that will hold 50.1 percent of the voting power. Alongside it, a Long-Term Benefit Trust of five financially disinterested trustees holds a special class of stock that lets it elect a majority of the board. The company says the arrangement "has no direct public company precedent," and the claim is plausible: founders keeping control is common, but founders keeping control while a separate trust, with no economic stake, picks most of the directors is not. The cofounders have also each pledged to give away 80 percent of their personal equity. Read generously, this is a mast. The founders expect that quarterly pressure from public markets will someday sing, and they are tying the company's safety commitments to something the market can't easily outvote.

Precommitment is one of the more admirable things a person can do, and it is worth saying why before complicating it. Most people are better at seeing their future weakness than at resisting it when it arrives. The person who deletes the app, tells friends she's quitting smoking, or puts savings where she can't touch them isn't surrendering her freedom. She is exercising the most mature form of it: the self that can see clearly governing the self that won't. Freedom that consists only in doing whatever you want in each moment is closer to being pushed around by the moment. On this view, binding yourself is how you remain the author of your life rather than its weather.

The objection comes from Elster himself. In the preface to Ulysses Unbound, the 2000 book in which he revisited his earlier theory, he quoted the Norwegian historian Jens Arup Seip: "In politics, people never try to bind themselves, only to bind others." Elster called the line too stark and still conceded it was closer to the truth than his own earlier view that constitutions were mainly a people binding itself.

That one sentence changes the story. Odysseus tied only himself, and his crew agreed. In a company, the people tied to the mast are mostly not the people who did the tying. The founders keep the vote. It is future shareholders who lose the ability to correct them, future employees who will work under rules they didn't choose, future leaders who inherit commitments made in a different era. When founders say they are protecting the mission from their own future temptations, Seip would ask whose hands are actually bound. The founders' future selves are the ones holding the rope.

There is an obvious reply, and it is a good one. Dual-class control is nothing new. Google and Meta went public with founders holding super-voting shares, and investors bought in with their eyes open. Nobody is forced to own Anthropic stock. Every buyer reads the same filing, sees the same 50.1 percent, and decides the price accordingly. Consent, on this view, is exactly what Odysseus's crew gave him, and the market gives it again with every trade.

That answer works for Google and fails here, for a reason the filing itself supplies. At Google and Meta, founder control protected a founder's vision of the business, and the people bound by it were mostly shareholders who could sell. Anthropic is binding itself for a different stated reason: the S-1 warns that advanced AI systems could "take harmful actions independently and at scale without human intervention." If that risk is real, the people with a stake in the rope are not only buyers of stock. They are everyone the technology reaches, and none of them signed anything. Investor consent covers the investors. It can't cover the bystanders on whose behalf the mast was supposedly built.

So the test I would apply to any precommitment has three parts: the person bound is the person binding, the danger is foreseeable, and there is a way to untie the knot if the judgment behind it turns out to be wrong. Anthropic passes the second clearly. It fails the first, since the rope runs mostly around other people. The third is more interesting. According to coverage of the filing, the founders' special voting share ends once fewer than three of the seven remain in the LLC for 90 consecutive days, and the trust, whose trustees hold no financial stake, is a separate check on the board. That is a way back, though it is triggered by the founders leaving rather than by anyone deciding they were wrong. A knot that loosens only when the people who tied it walk away is still their knot.

The most famous part of the myth is the wax. Odysseus plugged his crew's ears so they could hear neither the song nor his pleading, and the mast held because the people around him had been made deaf to both. Anthropic has the mast and the rope. What it cannot do is plug anyone's ears. Its employees, its trustees and its future shareholders will hear every quarter's song in full, and the arrangement will hold only as long as they choose, each time, to keep rowing past it.

— The Andes