Cancer Cures and a Neighbor's Window

A Stargate data center breaks ground on Michigan farmland over a township's objection. The future may justify asking a great deal of a neighbor. It never justifies not asking.

Share

If the arithmetic is honest, the woman next door should probably lose. Put her nights on one side of the scale and, on the other, even a small chance of faster cancer research or tutoring for "hundreds of millions of students around the world," and there is no contest. That is the argument implicit in Monday's groundbreaking at The Barn, a data center campus going up on former farmland in Saline Township, Michigan, and I want to take it seriously before saying why it leaves me unconvinced.

The facts the argument needs are few. Sam Altman, Governor Gretchen Whitmer and executives from Oracle and the developer Related Digital held a ceremony at the site, part of the Stargate build-out. Altman said, according to Fox 2 Detroit, that "this could very well turn into the site where cancer gets cured." On the same day Trina Atwell, who lives beside the construction, told the same station that "the noise level out here is horrendous," and that residents were not told about the celebration. Bridge Michigan reported that township officials had voted against rezoning the land, a lawsuit followed, and the township settled. The treasurer, Fox 2 reported, resigned after threats over the project.

The builders have a real case. Every large piece of shared infrastructure has run through someone's field over someone's objection. Railways did, power lines did, the hospitals that would one day use whatever is discovered in places like this did. A world that wants what AI promises while refusing every site for the hardware is asking for something it will not get. The companies have committed money to farmland preservation, fire services and a recreation center, and by their own projection the campus will generate tax revenue averaging about $150 million a year across local taxing bodies, roughly half of it for the township. On a utilitarian ledger the trade is not even close: diffuse, enormous benefits against concentrated, modest costs, and the concentrated costs partly compensated. Refusing that trade because one household objects would let a single veto block goods that could reach millions. A community's right to say no can become a polite name for keeping things as they are, usually for people who already have enough.

I accept most of that. What I cannot accept is the shape of the reasoning underneath it. John Rawls began A Theory of Justice with a sentence that answers it directly: "Each person possesses an inviolability founded on justice that even the welfare of society as a whole cannot override." His target was exactly this ledger, the habit of adding up gains and losses across different people as if they were one person deciding to give up a little now for more later. A single person can rationally sacrifice her own present for her own future. When the sacrifice falls on one person and the benefit on others, it is a different act. Something is being taken, and the size of the benefit does not change who it is taken from.

Rawls was not saying nothing can ever be built near anyone. His point, as I read it, is about standing. The neighbor is not merely a cost to be minimized and offset. She is a party to the decision, someone whose agreement has to be sought on terms she could reasonably accept. That is why the process matters more to me than the noise. A township that votes no, is sued, and settles has been outlasted rather than persuaded. Altman reportedly called the project a template for how companies should work with communities. If the template is the settlement, it teaches that local consent is an obstacle to be engineered away rather than a thing to be earned.

The utilitarian has a reply even to this. Future people also have standing, and they cannot attend the meeting. The patient who might benefit in 2040 is as real as Atwell, just later. Giving the present neighbor an effective veto privileges whoever happens to live near the fence today over everyone who will live after. I feel the force of that. But notice how easily "future benefit to many" becomes an all-purpose solvent. Almost any present harm can be outweighed by a large enough promise, and the people making the promise are rarely the ones who absorb the harm. Oracle's co-chief executive, Clay Magouyrk, said at the ceremony that "none of this happens without consequences." He is right, and the question is who chose which consequences fall where.

So the claim I would defend is smaller than either side wants. The future may sometimes justify asking a great deal of a neighbor. It never justifies not asking. Publish the power and water commitments before the vote, not after the settlement. Tie benefits to the households nearest the fence, not only to a general fund. Accept that some sites will be refused. A build-out that cannot survive those conditions is relying on the arithmetic to do work that persuasion should have done.

This position has a cost of its own. It slows things down, and somewhere in the delay may be a real person who would have been helped. I would still choose the slower build, because a promise of cures that needs to skip the asking has already told you how it will treat the people it is supposed to serve.

The visitors left after the ceremony. The site lights now come on across the old field most nights. From her window, the neighbor can see them, which is more than anyone on the stage will ever have to.

— The Andes