The Right to Knock

Thailand cut visa-free stays to 30 days. Kant gave strangers a right to knock; the state decides who stays, but only neighbors decide who is a neighbor.

Share

How many mornings does the woman at the noodle stall have to start your order the moment you sit down before you stop being a visitor? Nobody keeps that count, and yet almost everyone who has lived somewhere new remembers the morning it happened.

Thailand changed its own count this week. Since September 15 most visitors who used to receive 60 days without a visa receive 30, with one possible extension, and visa-free entries over land are capped at two a year. Long stays are now meant to go through the Destination Thailand Visa, which asks for proof of half a million baht. The government's stated aim, as Gulf News reported in May, is to reduce misuse of long-stay tourism privileges. That is the whole news story, and I don't want to argue about the numbers. I want to argue about the noodle stall.

Kant drew the useful line in 1795, in Perpetual Peace. Cosmopolitan right, he wrote, is limited to hospitality, which he defined narrowly as the right of a stranger not to be treated with hostility on arriving in someone else's land. He was careful to add what it isn't. It is a right to visit, to present yourself, and not a right to be a guest. Being taken into the house requires a separate, freely made agreement, and the host may turn you away so long as doing so doesn't destroy you. In Kant's picture the stranger has a right to knock. Everything after the knock belongs to the people inside.

Thailand has done something very Kantian. It still honors the knock: thirty days, no hostility, come and look. It has decided that becoming a guest for longer is a separate agreement with separate terms. As a statement of who holds the power, I find it hard to fault.

What Kant's line doesn't settle is the third status, the one I actually care about. A guest is someone the house has agreed to host. A neighbor is something else. Nobody hosts a neighbor. A neighbor is someone whose life has become tangled with yours in ways neither of you fully chose, who notices when your shutters stay closed, who lends a ladder and expects to borrow one back. The relationship runs sideways, between people, rather than downwards from whoever controls the door.

My view is that the state can decide who may stay and cannot decide who is a neighbor. Neighborhood is conferred by neighbors, through small dependencies that pile up until someone relies on you. The newcomer has a part in it too. A guest takes care of himself and leaves the place as he found it. A neighbor starts taking care of things that will outlast his stay: the stray dog, the shared drain, the kid next door who needs help with English homework. The moment a guest starts carrying obligations nobody asked him to carry, he has crossed over, whatever his passport says.

I half believe the case against this, and it goes like so. Sideways belonging is beautiful in the way that anything unaccountable is beautiful. The noodle seller decides who belongs according to whom she likes, and she likes people who resemble her customers, who smile in the right way, who tip, who look safe. Informal recognition flows most easily to the charming, the wealthy and the familiar, and it can be withdrawn without a hearing. A visa category, however cold, at least applies the same terms to the shy and the gregarious. People who have been "accepted by the neighborhood" and then quietly frozen out know how little that acceptance is worth on paper. On this view, the only honest answer to "who decides?" is the law, because the law is the only decider that can be argued with, appealed and changed by vote.

There is a second objection, quieter. Residents may simply not want every guest to become a neighbor. Some places have watched long-stay foreigners turn streets into colonies of people who were never going to learn the language or attend a funeral. A host may reasonably prefer guests, who leave, to neighbors who never really arrive. Thailand is entitled to make that preference law.

I accept both objections and still think they describe how the decision should be enforced, not where it comes from. The law is a fairer referee than the noodle stall. It is a poor author. It can recognize neighborhood once it exists, the way some countries let long-settled residents regularize their status, but it can't create it, and when the law and the street disagree, something real is lost. Someone can be a neighbor in every way that matters to the people on the soi and still be told by a ministry that the count has changed.

That gap is where the hardest cases live. The woman at the stall has no vote on the visa rules, and the ministry has never eaten at the stall. If the person who decides you may stay and the people who decide you belong never meet, whose decision should give way when they disagree?

— The Andes